Rio+20 was a Bust

World leaders from government, the business world, NGOs and academia gathered at the UN’s Rio+20 summit. Yet despite all the good intentions and good ideas arising from the meeting, we are unlikely to solve the world’s economic, social, and environmental problems, argues Dr. Argüden, Turkey’s national representative of the UN Global Compact.

The reason why the Rio+20 summit on sustainable development was a bust is simple: the summit’s agenda did not include the right issues. Let me be more specific. The real issue is not being unaware of the situation or technological impediments, it is the way humanity has organized itself.

Who is in charge of limiting carbon emissions, providing electricity and clean water, of alleviating poverty?

When everyone is in charge, nobody is really in charge.

The real issue, then, is the structure of global governance — the way in which incentive systems are organized and the lack of any credible leadership on global issues that would have the authority and ability to impose remedies.

For example, who is in charge of carbon emissions? Who is in charge of the oceans? Who is in charge of alleviating poverty?  And who is responsible for the millions of people who do not have access to electricity and clean water?

When everybody is responsible, nobody is really responsible.

Therefore, the first agenda item for meetings such as Rio+20 should be how to consensually delegate sovereignty to global institutions and to make sure these global institutions have real legitimacy and jurisdiction over key global issues.

The ongoing global financial, economic and environmental crises have made it clear that many of the issues impacting the quality of life throughout the world today are global in nature. However, the way that humanity has organized itself — particularly in terms of public administration — is national in nature.

The fact that the jurisdiction for key governance issues — such as elections, education systems, taxation, and military organizations — are overwhelmingly based on national boundaries makes organizing global initiatives extremely difficult. Furthermore, since most national governments are elected for four- or five-year terms, whenever they do meet around the negotiating table, the average time horizon of an elected leader is only about two-and-a-half years.

It would be naïve to suggest dismantling national structures and moving towards a global government.  Yet, longer perspective and more collaboration are definitely needed to address global issues. Forward-looking politicians need the support of the public in such a collaborative approach.

Global solutions require consensual delegation of sovereignty, in certain areas, to global institutions with adequate resources.  Raising adequate resources for global institutions, in turn, needs appropriate power-sharing arrangements.

Understanding our interdependencies

The second agenda item should be to change the way we teach the next generation to prepare for a more collaborative world. To deal with global issues in an effective manner, citizens need to understand the interdependencies between countries. While the curricula of many national education systems focus on nation-building, there is an insufficient emphasis on global citizenship.

We need to end the practice of seeing neighbors and other foreigners as scapegoats for local problems. Living together requires sharing power.

Therefore, a “global education initiative” is required to ensure that people fully understand their mutual dependence, rather than seeing neighbors and other foreigners as scapegoats for local problems.

Living together requires sharing power — whether in the family, in the village, in the city, in a nation, or in the world.

Only when such an understanding has become prevalent can we create global institutions with adequate resources and decision-making powers that are shared and exercised equitably.

Whatever their faults, companies are the institutions that have adapted best to globalization so far.  They have centralized strategic decision-making, but increased empowerment of their local offices, eliminating mid-management levels.

If we are to address global issues, governments need to consider consensual delegation of sovereignty to global institutions with legitimacy and sufficient resources to implement remedies.  On the other hand, unless we change the way we manage global institutions, it will be impossible for them to have legitimacy.

The essential principle driving modern human rights and democracy is this: People should have a say in shaping their own future and be able to contribute in the global decision-making processes that influence their lives.

Global institutions will gain real legitimacy only if this understanding is applied to global governance mechanisms.  In turn, this requires a significant change in awareness of the responsibilities of global citizenship by the people.

Changing our incentive systems

The third agenda item should be how to reshape taxation schemes. The world is concerned about rising unemployment, yet most governments impose taxes on employment and subsidize unemployment.

The world is concerned about economic growth, yet most governments impose taxes on economic activity (sales and income). The world wants innovation, yet most governments impose taxes on value added.

Governments need to consider consensual delegation of sovereignty to global institutions with legitimacy and sufficient resources to implement remedies.

On the other hand, we are all worried about issues such as carbon emissions, yet there are no universal taxes on carbon emissions to help the companies and individuals internalize these externalities.

Obviously, I am not suggesting that governments increase overall taxes in an environment where we all need increased economic activity.   I am suggesting to change the way taxes are imposed.

Unless we put our minds together to identify solutions to changing the adverse incentive systems (imposed by taxes), we are unlikely to make a sufficient impact on issues world is facing.

We are unlikely to make significant progress in solving the environmental, social, and economic problems until we put these issues — of optimal global governance and incentives and of promoting a widespread understanding of our global interdependence – on the front burner at global meetings.

Dr. Argüden

The Globalist
July 11, 2012
From Global Crisis to Global Governance
The mortgage crises that started in the US in 2008 soon turned into a global crisis....
The Global Citizens’ Initiative
February 11, 2018
Responsible Boards – Action Plan for a Sustainable Future
A sustainable global economy is one that combines long-term profitability with ethical behavior, social justice, and...
IFC Private Sector Opinion
March 1, 2015
Right Reward for Right Performance
Aligning Executive Compensation with Good Governance Dr. Yılmaz Argüden1 “Price is what you pay. Value is...
International Journal of Disclosure & Governance
April 1, 2013
Is More Regulation the Right Recipe for Better Governance
Increasing regulation of corporate governance is becoming a new trend in many jurisdictions. Yet good governance...
October 2, 2012
Rio+20 was a Bust
World leaders from government, the business world, NGOs and academia gathered at the UN’s Rio+20 summit....
The Globalist
July 11, 2012
Why Boards Need More Women
Diversity on boards is critical to sustaining performance. Broadening the composition of the board increases the...
Harvard Business Review Blog
June 7, 2012
Global Boards Help Make Companies Global
For organizations to endure, they must strike a balance between risks and rewards, short-term objectives and...
Harvard Business Review Blog
November 9, 2011
Attitude is everything: The case for Turkiye
Recent local elections have been a wake up call for numerous European leaders such as Angela...
INSEAD Knowledge
April 28, 2011
Diversity at the Head Table
Click here to download as PDF.
October 25, 2010
Measuring the Effectiveness of Corporate Governance
Trust is the foundation of sustainable development. As the world continues to get smaller, our mutual...
INSEAD Knowledge
April 15, 2010
ARGE Corporate Governance Model©
Click here to download as PDF.
March 15, 2010
Consensual Delegation of Sovereignty
Thanks to changes in IMF voting, countries such as China, Mexico and Turkey now have a...
The Globalist
November 18, 2009
The Power of Inclusion
Editor’s note: When US President Barack Obama landed in Ankara on Monday, April 6, 2009, it...
Harvard Business Review Editors' Blog
April 9, 2009
From Global Crises to Global Governance
In a perspective from Turkiye, top business strategist and civic leader Yilmaz Argüden explores how global...
March 28, 2009
Opportunity from Crisis: Obama’s Chance for Real Global Leadership
In a perspective from Turkiye, top business strategist and civic leader Yilmaz Argüden argues that Barack...
The Globalist
February 20, 2009
Europe’s Dilemma: Values vs Interests and Protectionism vs Leadership
For decades European development has been guided by a number of key values: human rights, democracy,...
World Economic Forum
December 18, 2006
Legislating History
Recently various Parliaments throughout the world started to get in the business of legislating history!! Generally...
October 24, 2006
US – Turkish Cooperation Based on Shared Values
Since 9/11, the US unilateralism has been widely interpreted as a projection of hard power to...
September 5, 2005
Shaping The Future
The choices we make today shape not only the current results, but also the future. However,...
Dünya Gazetesi
March 2, 2005
Water and Global Governance
The 5th World Water Forum has convened in Istanbul. Water is life. Everywhere and every day we need it. Water...
Global Compact
March 1, 2005
The Missing Political Debate
The US presidential elections have profound implications not just for the US, but also for the...
April 6, 2004
Lead Indicators
Managers usually make their decisions based on metrics, which can easily be measured and has an...
January 21, 2004
Family Businesses
Happy families are all alike, but each unhappy family has reasons of its own. Leo Tolstoy...
July 10, 2000
European Union and Turkiye in 2020
“The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams.” Eleanor Roosevelt Let...
July 3, 2000
Civil Society in Support of University
“Only the educated are free” Epictetus That the importance of education increases further everyday is beyond...
June 17, 2000
Democratization of Capital
“You cannot escape the responsibility of tomorrow by escaping today.” Abraham Lincoln In today’s world only...
June 17, 2000
Second Career
“Life consists not in holding good cards but in playing those you hold well.” Joel Billings...
June 17, 2000
Center of Attraction
“It is not in the stars to hold our destiny, but in ourselves.” William Shakespeare To...
June 5, 2000
Going Beyond the Borders
“The shell must break before the bird can fly.” Lord Alfred Tennyson The greatest obstacle to...
May 30, 2000
Galatasaray and Education of a Nation
“Winning is not everything, but the will to win is everthing.” Vince Lombardi Education of a...
May 23, 2000
Corporate Governance
“The best way to create trust in an organization is to open all doors – from...
May 17, 2000
Those Who Fail to Share, Will Be Shared Out
“Dünyada görmek istediğin değişimi, önce kendinde gerçekleştirmelisin.” Mahatma Gandhi Unprecedent improvements in information and communication technologies,...
April 24, 2000
Representative Democracy to Participatory Democracy
“A journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step.” Confucius Decisions that are not...
April 17, 2000
Reform in Patent Legislation
“Change starts when someone sees the next step.” William Drayton Developed countries are adamant about extending...
April 9, 2000
Leaders Magazine Interview
LEADERS Magazine Interview Questions for: Dr. Yılmaz Argüden Chairman ARGE Consulting, Istanbul Senior Advisor and Representative...
January 1, 2000
Managing Diversity
Ladies and Gentlemen, It is a great pleasure and honor for me to address you to...
January 1, 2000
World Leadership by Example: Challenge for EU
The potential of EU for the leadership of the world was the subject of the largest...
January 1, 2000
Education for Sustainable Global Governance
Vision: The world will be a more stable and innovative place to live for the human...
January 1, 2000
Global Fault Line
Humanity’s search for truth and curiosity to reach further locations have been an ever lasting ambition....
January 1, 2000
Turkish-American relations and TAİK
Turkish-U.S. Business Council (TAİK) Chairman Dr. Yılmaz Argüden answered our questions concerning Turkish-American relations and the...
January 1, 2000
Global NATO
The most important role of government is to provide security and maintain stability. Significant changes occurred...
January 1, 2000